REVIEW 3 major objections 1 minor 48 references
Lower-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity supports regular black holes and black-bounces when matter sectors are reconstructed from the field equations or via a unimodular extension.
Reviewed by Pith at T0; open to challenge. T0 means a machine referee read the full paper against a public rubric. the ladder, T0–T4 →
T0 review · grok-4.3
2026-06-27 05:55 UTC pith:TK3B3RN2
load-bearing objection The paper builds explicit regular black holes and black-bounces in lower-dimensional EGB by deriving NED Lagrangians from the field equations and adding a unimodular extension, but the inversion step for L(F) carries a real consistency risk. the 3 major comments →
Geometrically Regular Black Object Solutions in Lower-Dimensional Gauss-Bonnet Gravity and Its Unimodular Extension
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
Regular compact objects are obtained in lower-dimensional EGB gravity by deriving nonlinear electrodynamics Lagrangians from the field equations or by formulating a unimodular extension in which Maxwell fields support regularity through a dynamical, spacetime-dependent cosmological function.
What carries the argument
Nonlinear electrodynamics Lagrangian obtained by solving the field equations, together with the spacetime-dependent cosmological function in the unimodular extension.
Load-bearing premise
The nonlinear electrodynamics Lagrangians and spacetime-dependent cosmological function can be chosen or derived without introducing inconsistencies, energy-condition violations, or instabilities.
What would settle it
Explicit calculation showing that the derived nonlinear electrodynamics Lagrangians produce negative energy densities or dynamical instabilities at the regular center would falsify the claim that regularity is restored.
If this is right
- Thermodynamic quantities are modified so that evaporation leads to remnant formation rather than complete disappearance.
- Nontrivial phase transitions appear in the heat capacity and other thermodynamic potentials.
- Black-bounce solutions recover the standard EGB-BTZ thermodynamics in the appropriate limit.
- Curvature invariants remain finite everywhere, including at the throat or center.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The dynamical cosmological function mechanism might extend to other higher-curvature theories where vacuum solutions are singular.
- Thermodynamic remnants could connect to information-loss questions if the matter sector is quantized.
- The same reconstruction technique for Lagrangians could be applied to other lower-dimensional modified gravities to test regularity.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper claims to construct regular black-hole and black-bounce solutions in lower-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet (EGB) gravity by deriving nonlinear electrodynamics (NED) Lagrangians directly from the field equations to restore regularity while preserving BTZ-like asymptotics, and by formulating a unimodular extension with a spacetime-dependent cosmological function that enables standard Maxwell fields to support regular geometries via dynamical vacuum-matter exchange. Thermodynamic properties are analyzed, showing modified evaporation, remnant formation, and phase transitions, with black-bounce quantities recovering EGB-BTZ limits.
Significance. If the derivations prove consistent without circularity or hidden inconsistencies, the work offers a concrete laboratory for regular compact objects in higher-curvature gravity, explicitly linking NED and unimodular mechanisms to singularity resolution and thermodynamics; the attempt to derive Lagrangians from field equations and the smooth thermodynamic recovery in the black-bounce limit are notable strengths.
major comments (3)
- [NED derivation] In the section deriving electromagnetic Lagrangians from the field equations (abstract and NED construction paragraphs): the inversion step to obtain L(F) from the metric ansatz implicitly assumes a single-valued function of the invariant F = F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} that reproduces the full EOM including Bianchi identities; no explicit verification of this is reported, which is load-bearing for the claimed consistency of the regular solutions.
- [Unimodular extension] In the unimodular extension analysis: the spacetime-dependent cosmological function mediates energy exchange between vacuum and Maxwell sectors, yet no check is provided that the resulting effective stress-energy satisfies the dominant energy condition everywhere, undermining the physical viability of the regular geometries.
- [Thermodynamics] In the thermodynamic properties section: claims that the matter sector modifies evaporation and allows remnant formation rest on the derived NED Lagrangians and dynamical \Lambda(x); if these are reverse-engineered from the metric rather than independently constrained, the thermodynamic conclusions lose force.
minor comments (1)
- A brief recap of the regularized dimensional reduction procedure for lower-dimensional EGB would help readers, as the abstract assumes familiarity with the vacuum solution's singularity.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their thorough review and valuable comments, which help clarify several aspects of our work. We address each major comment below and indicate where revisions will be made to strengthen the manuscript.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: In the section deriving electromagnetic Lagrangians from the field equations (abstract and NED construction paragraphs): the inversion step to obtain L(F) from the metric ansatz implicitly assumes a single-valued function of the invariant F = F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} that reproduces the full EOM including Bianchi identities; no explicit verification of this is reported, which is load-bearing for the claimed consistency of the regular solutions.
Authors: The Lagrangians are obtained by direct substitution of the metric ansatz into the field equations and solving for L(F), ensuring by construction that the Einstein equations are satisfied. We acknowledge that an explicit verification of consistency with the Bianchi identities and single-valuedness of L(F) was not included. In the revised manuscript we will add this verification, confirming that the derived L(F) is single-valued in the relevant range of F and that the full set of equations (including Bianchi) holds identically. revision: yes
-
Referee: In the unimodular extension analysis: the spacetime-dependent cosmological function mediates energy exchange between vacuum and Maxwell sectors, yet no check is provided that the resulting effective stress-energy satisfies the dominant energy condition everywhere, undermining the physical viability of the regular geometries.
Authors: We agree that an explicit check of the dominant energy condition (DEC) for the effective stress-energy tensor is necessary to assess physical viability. Although the construction guarantees regularity and the correct asymptotics, the DEC was not verified in the original text. We will add this analysis in the revision, showing that the DEC holds throughout the spacetime except possibly in a small neighborhood of the origin where the matter sector dominates. revision: yes
-
Referee: In the thermodynamic properties section: claims that the matter sector modifies evaporation and allows remnant formation rest on the derived NED Lagrangians and dynamical \Lambda(x); if these are reverse-engineered from the metric rather than independently constrained, the thermodynamic conclusions lose force.
Authors: The NED Lagrangians and the spacetime-dependent cosmological function are obtained by solving the field equations for the chosen regular metric functions; they are therefore dynamically constrained rather than arbitrarily chosen. We will revise the relevant sections to emphasize this derivation procedure and its direct link to the thermodynamic quantities, thereby clarifying that the evaporation and remnant results follow from solutions that satisfy the equations of motion. revision: yes
Circularity Check
NED Lagrangians obtained by inverting field equations on pre-chosen regular metrics
specific steps
-
fitted input called prediction
[Abstract]
"First, we derive regular black-hole solutions supported by nonlinear electrodynamics and determine the corresponding electromagnetic Lagrangians directly from the field equations."
Regular metrics are selected first to eliminate the curvature singularity; the field equations are then solved for the stress-energy and inverted to produce L(F). The resulting Lagrangian is therefore fitted to the desired geometry rather than independently specified, rendering the regularity support tautological.
-
self definitional
[Abstract]
"we formulate a unimodular extension of lower-dimensional EGB gravity and show that standard Maxwell fields can support regular geometries through a dynamical exchange between the vacuum and matter sectors mediated by a spacetime-dependent cosmological function."
The unimodular extension is defined and introduced precisely to enable the dynamical \Lambda(x) that restores regularity; the claimed support is therefore built into the formulation of the extension itself.
full rationale
The central construction begins by positing regular metric ansatze (BTZ-like asymptotics with finite curvature at origin), substitutes into the EGB equations to extract the required T_{\mu u}, and then inverts to obtain L(F). This step makes regularity an input rather than an output. The unimodular extension is likewise introduced specifically to permit a dynamical \Lambda(x) that exchanges energy with Maxwell fields to achieve the same regularity. While the paper performs explicit calculations and thermodynamic analysis, the load-bearing matter-sector step reduces to construction by design. No self-citation chains or uniqueness theorems are invoked as external justification.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
free parameters (2)
- nonlinear electrodynamics scale parameters
- spacetime-dependent cosmological function
axioms (2)
- domain assumption The regularized dimensional reduction procedure yields a consistent lower-dimensional EGB theory whose vacuum solution has a curvature singularity.
- domain assumption The asymptotic BTZ-like structure must be preserved while restoring regularity at the origin.
read the original abstract
We investigate the construction of regular compact objects in the recently proposed lower-dimensional Einstein--Gauss--Bonnet (EGB) gravity obtained through regularized dimensional reduction. Unlike the standard BTZ black hole, the corresponding vacuum EGB solution develops a genuine curvature singularity at the origin, providing an interesting setting in which higher-curvature corrections deteriorate the ultraviolet behavior of spacetime. To address this issue, we reconstruct matter sectors capable of restoring regularity while preserving the BTZ-like asymptotic structure. First, we derive regular black-hole solutions supported by nonlinear electrodynamics and determine the corresponding electromagnetic Lagrangians directly from the field equations. We then extend the analysis to Simpson--Visser black-bounce geometries, obtaining smooth throat configurations with finite curvature invariants throughout the spacetime. As an alternative regularization mechanism, we formulate a unimodular extension of lower-dimensional EGB gravity and show that standard Maxwell fields can support regular geometries through a dynamical exchange between the vacuum and matter sectors mediated by a spacetime-dependent cosmological function. We further investigate the thermodynamic properties of the regular black-hole and black-bounce solutions, showing that the matter sector modifies the evaporation process, allows for remnant formation, and produces nontrivial phase transitions. In the black-bounce case, the thermodynamic quantities smoothly recover the EGB-BTZ behavior in the appropriate limit. These results demonstrate that lower-dimensional EGB gravity provides a useful laboratory for exploring the interplay between higher-curvature corrections, regular compact objects, nonlinear electrodynamics, and unimodular gravity.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Lovelock, The Einstein tensor and its generalizations, J
D. Lovelock, The Einstein tensor and its generalizations, J. Math. Phys.12, 498 (1971)
1971
-
[2]
D. Glavan and C. Lin, Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet Gravity in Four-Dimensional Spacetime, Phys. Rev. Lett.124, 081301 (2020), arXiv:1905.03601 [gr-qc]
- [3]
- [4]
-
[5]
Casimir wormholes inspired by electric charge in Ein- stein–Gauss–Bonnet gravity
M. S. Cunha, M. O. Tahim, and C. R. Muniz, Remarks on “Casimir wormholes inspired by electric charge in Ein- stein–Gauss–Bonnet gravity”, Commun. Theor. Phys.77, 085402 (2025)
2025
-
[6]
M. G¨ urses, T. c. S ¸i¸ sman, and B. Tekin, Is there a novel Einstein–Gauss–Bonnet theory in four dimensions?, Eur. Phys. J. C80, 647 (2020), arXiv:2004.03390 [gr-qc]. 22
- [7]
-
[8]
J. Arrechea, A. Delhom, and A. Jim´ enez-Cano, Inconsistencies in four-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet gravity, Chin. Phys. C45, 013107 (2021), arXiv:2004.12998 [gr-qc]
- [9]
- [10]
- [11]
- [12]
-
[13]
The Black Hole in Three Dimensional Space Time
M. Banados, C. Teitelboim, and J. Zanelli, The Black hole in three-dimensional space-time, Phys. Rev. Lett.69, 1849 (1992), arXiv:hep-th/9204099
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 1992
-
[14]
The (2+1)-Dimensional Black Hole
S. Carlip, The (2+1)-Dimensional black hole, Class. Quant. Grav.12, 2853 (1995), arXiv:gr-qc/9506079
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 1995
-
[15]
R. A. Konoplya, Influence of the back reaction of the Hawking radiation upon black hole quasinormal modes, Phys. Rev. D70, 047503 (2004), arXiv:hep-th/0406100
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2004
- [16]
-
[17]
Regular Black Hole in General Relativity Coupled to Nonlinear Electrodynamics
E. Ayon-Beato and A. Garcia, Regular black hole in general relativity coupled to nonlinear electrodynamics, Phys. Rev. Lett.80, 5056 (1998), arXiv:gr-qc/9911046
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 1998
-
[18]
The Bardeen Model as a Nonlinear Magnetic Monopole
E. Ayon-Beato and A. Garcia, The Bardeen model as a nonlinear magnetic monopole, Phys. Lett. B493, 149 (2000), arXiv:gr-qc/0009077
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2000
- [19]
- [20]
-
[21]
C. R. Muniz, J. A. Rebou¸ cas, L. T. de Oliveira, F. T. B. Sampaio, and F. B. Lustosa, Regularized black hole solution from a new string cloud source, Phys. Dark Univ.52, 102272 (2026), arXiv:2511.11419 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2026
- [22]
-
[23]
Black-bounce to traversable wormhole
A. Simpson and M. Visser, Black-bounce to traversable wormhole, JCAP02, 042, arXiv:1812.07114 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv
-
[24]
E. Franzin, S. Liberati, J. Mazza, A. Simpson, and M. Visser, Charged black-bounce spacetimes, JCAP07, 036, arXiv:2104.11376 [gr-qc]
- [25]
- [26]
-
[27]
J. Furtado and G. Alencar, BTZ Black-Bounce to Traversable Wormhole, Universe8, 625 (2022), arXiv:2210.06608 [gr-qc]
-
[28]
G. F. R. Ellis, H. van Elst, J. Murugan, and J.-P. Uzan, On the Trace-Free Einstein Equations as a Viable Alternative to General Relativity, Class. Quant. Grav.28, 225007 (2011), arXiv:1008.1196 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2011
-
[29]
G. Alencar and T. M. Crispim, The scalar–Maxwell–L(x) system: Wormhole spacetimes without nonlinear electrody- namics in unimodular gravity, (2026), arXiv:2603.30003 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2026
-
[30]
Regular Black Strings and BTZ Black Hole in Unimodular Gravity Supported by Maxwell Fields
G. Alencar and V. H. U. Borralho, Regular Black Strings and BTZ Black Hole in Unimodular Gravity Supported by Maxwell Fields, (2026), arXiv:2604.00078 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2026
-
[31]
G. Alencar, T. M. Crispim, J. Macedo, and C. R. Muniz, Lower-dimensional Gauss-Bonnet gravity black holes with quintessence, Nucl. Phys. B1024, 117337 (2026), arXiv:2603.03408 [gr-qc]
- [32]
- [33]
- [34]
-
[35]
G. Alencar, T. M. Crispim, D. S´ aez-Chill´ on G´ omez, and M. V. d. S. Silva, Black bounce as a quantum correction from string T-duality: Thermodynamics, energy conditions, and observational imprints from EHT, (2026), arXiv:2603.05543 [gr-qc]
-
[36]
Geometrical aspects of light propagation in nonlinear electrodynamics
M. Novello, V. A. De Lorenci, J. M. Salim, and R. Klippert, Geometrical aspects of light propagation in nonlinear electrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D61, 045001 (2000), arXiv:gr-qc/9911085
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2000
- [37]
-
[38]
C. A. M. de Melo, L. G. Medeiros, and P. J. Pompeia, Causal Structure and Birefringence in Nonlinear Electrodynamics, Mod. Phys. Lett. A30, 1550025 (2015), arXiv:1407.0567 [hep-th]. 23
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2015
- [39]
-
[40]
Nonlinear electrodynamics as a symmetric hyperbolic system
F. Abalos, F. Carrasco, ´E. Goulart, and O. Reula, Nonlinear electrodynamics as a symmetric hyperbolic system, Phys. Rev. D92, 084024 (2015), arXiv:1507.02262 [gr-qc]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2015
- [41]
-
[42]
Alencar, Maxwell-supported regular black holes in unimodular gravity,https://inspirehep.net/literature/ 3137491(2026), iNSPIRE entry
G. Alencar, Maxwell-supported regular black holes in unimodular gravity,https://inspirehep.net/literature/ 3137491(2026), iNSPIRE entry
2026
-
[43]
Henneaux and C
M. Henneaux and C. Teitelboim, The Cosmological Constant and General Covariance, Phys. Lett. B222, 195 (1989)
1989
-
[44]
K. V. Kuchar, Does an unspecified cosmological constant solve the problem of time in quantum gravity?, Phys. Rev. D 43, 3332 (1991)
1991
-
[45]
Conformal and non Conformal Dilaton Gravity
E. Alvarez, M. Herrero-Valea, and C. P. Martin, Conformal and non Conformal Dilaton Gravity, JHEP10, 115, arXiv:1404.0806 [hep-th]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv
-
[46]
How unimodular gravity theories differ from general relativity at quantum level
R. Bufalo, M. Oksanen, and A. Tureanu, How unimodular gravity theories differ from general relativity at quantum level, Eur. Phys. J. C75, 477 (2015), arXiv:1505.04978 [hep-th]
work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2015
-
[47]
R. M. Wald, Black hole entropy is the noether charge, Physical Review D48, R3427 (1993)
1993
-
[48]
Iyer and R
V. Iyer and R. M. Wald, Some properties of noether charge and a proposal for dynamical black hole entropy, Physical Review D50, 846 (1994)
1994
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.